Showing posts with label free market. Show all posts
Showing posts with label free market. Show all posts

Thursday, June 23, 2016

The Non-Explanation of the "Love of Money"

Explaining market operations by invoking "the love of money" is as nonsensical as explaining them by invoking "the love of language". Both money and language are indispensable tools for engaging in large-scale social cooperation based on productive specialization and division of labor, but neither is its goal. The fact that only the former is routinely mistaken for it can only be explained by the influence of common envy masquerading as a psychological insight. As should be all too obvious, envy is the greed of the loser.

Saturday, September 26, 2015

"Profiteering" is an Exclusively Statist Practice

The free market continually eliminates profits through the process of competitive arbitrage. The state continually tries to sustain them by converting them into monopoly rents. In other words, "profiteering" is an exclusively statist practice. In a free market, to pursue profit successfully is to eliminate it. In a "regulated" market, to pursue profit successfully is to petrify it into a monopolistic, coercive privilege. Bear that in mind whenever you hear the flagrant nonsense about "free market greed".

Thursday, August 13, 2015

The Only Regulated Market is the Free Market

Whenever one contrasts free market and "regulated" market, he tries to play an Orwellian trick on you. The free market is by definiton regulated by the interactions of consumers and producers - producers regulate each other's plans through the process of entrepreneurial competition, while consumers regulate the plans of producers through the exercise of their sovereign buying decisions. The result is a wonderfully intricate, disciplined, and effective social organism that creates and distributes resources in as rational a way as the cognitive skills of all productive members of society make possible.

In view of the above, "regulating" the free market turns out to be nothing more than a euphemism for violently interfering with its operation, thus necessarily derailing its intricate allocative processes and effectively deregulating it in the worst sense of the term. You should never fall for this semantic trick. The choice is never between absolute freedom and regulation, but between regulation by the customer and regulation by the plunderer.

Friday, August 7, 2015

The Spontaneous Emergence and Deliberate Understanding of Free Markets

Free markets may emerge spontaneously, but the understanding of their crucial role has to be a deliberate, planned, and sustained effort of all their participants, lest they be spontaneously destroyed by the forces of economic and moral ignorance.

Saturday, August 1, 2015

The Beauty and Glory of Spontaneous Orders

Even if, from the God's-eye point of view, every human being is a hopeless illiterate, every natural language is nonetheless a masterpiece of literary and rhetorical art. Even if, from the God's-eye point of view, every merchant is an inveterate philistine, money is nonetheless one of the greatest tools for sophisticated social cooperation. Even if, from the God's-eye point of view, every entrepreneur is an incorrigible fool, the free market is nonetheless the greatest source of practical financial wisdom. That's the beauty and glory of spontaneous orders in a nutshell.

Monday, June 29, 2015

Is the Free Enterprise System Moral or Amoral?

Is the free enterprise system (otherwise known as laissez-faire, market libertarianism, etc.) amoral or moral? The answer is: it's both, and it's a doubly good thing.

On the one hand, it is amoral insofar as one of its primary competitive advantages is its impartial efficiency - due to its inherent institutional features, such as the competitive incentive structure, the intersubjective profit-and-loss-based price system, rapid aggregation of decentralized and tacit information, etc., it is peerlessly effective in promoting all kinds of social values, which may correspond to all kinds of moral and prudential systems. In this sense, the free enterprise system is the most effective means of pursuing individual satisfaction, which is a subjective, and thus an amoral concept.

But on the other hand, the free enterprise system is also inherently moral, since its indispensable institutional features embody all the cardinal virtues: prudence (the ability to forecast the uncertain future and create a viable business plan), courage (the willingness to take risks and disregard the conventional wisdom), temperance (the ability to delay gratification and commit one's resources to a long-term project), and justice (the necessity of fulfilling one's contractual obligations). In addition, since every voluntary transaction is necessarily a positive-sum game, and since the free enterprise system is necessarily based exclusively on such transactions, it is necessarily grounded in what might be called reciprocal philanthropy.

In sum, the free enterprise system is amoral insofar as it can effectively promote all kinds of social philosophies in their peaceful varieties (which is a good thing), and it is moral insofar as its inherent institutional structure instantiates the entrepreneurial-utilitarian virtues of courage, prudence, and temperance, the deontological virtue of justice, and the broadly humane virtue of reciprocal philanthropy (which, needless to say, is also a good thing).

Thus, three moral cheers for laissez-faire, since there is not only hardly anything as efficient, but also hardly anything as fair.

Saturday, June 27, 2015

On the Verge of the Second Entrepreneurial Turn

Up until recent days, the history of humankind has been primarily a history of organized violence – wars, conquests, raids, slavery, oppression, and persecution. Entrepreneurs provided goods and services, but the attention of both the common man and the social scientist has been turned primarily toward the ruling caste of parasitic exploiters. It seems likely that this unfortunate state of affairs has been chiefly the result of the operation of some of the more unsavory features of our evolutionary heritage.

And yet some encouraging things happened along the way. In roughly the 17th and 18th centuries, the combination of the right moral and economic ideas (spontaneous order theory, the concept of the invisible hand, and the philosophy of natural rights to life, liberty and property), their widespread dissemination through the printing press, and the migration to America of a self-selected group willing to create a new society built around these concepts ushered in a qualitatively different era. For the first time in history, the entrepreneur has been widely and explicitly recognized as the driving force of civilizational progress, while the ruler has been demoted to at best a necessary evil. The first entrepreneurial turn has taken place, and humankind has finally managed to shake off at least part of its unfortunate primordial heritage.

Since then there admittedly have been several bumps and reversals along the way from violent primitivism to peaceful civilization, but overcoming them has only made the relevant ideas and practices more robust and refined. To use Taleb’s phrase, entrepreneurship is anti-fragile, and so are the ideas that make the world safe for its unhindered development. In their original formulation, they conceded a role for organized violence and even suggested that it is necessary for the smooth operation of entrepreneurial ventures. Perhaps it was precisely this concession that allowed organized violence to feed off the wealth-creating energy of entrepreneurial individuals and grow more deadly than ever before. And perhaps it was precisely this unfortunate result that prompted the contemporary rethinking of the economic and ethical foundations of entrepreneurship.

If the defining features of the entrepreneurial market process – creative destruction, alertness to unexploited profit opportunities, and economic calculation projected into the uncertain future – are so conducive to the efficient production of goods and services, why should they not be equally conducive to the efficient production of institutional frameworks that facilitate their unhindered operation? This is the central question that propels the second entrepreneurial turn – the theoretical and practical exploration of entrepreneurship as a multi-level phenomenon, operating not only within given institutional frameworks, but across them as well, and seen not only as a result of their existence, but also as the driving force behind their emergence.

This question becomes particularly interesting and relevant in the context of entrepreneurial provision of law and order. There, logical reflection backed by ample empirical case studies suggests that entrepreneurial competition might be uniquely suited to instantiate the kind of institutional features that Enlightenment scholars attributed to the optimal form of government. For instance, it might be the case that a network of multiple private protection and arbitration agencies vying for clients on the basis of service quality is uniquely suited to establishing a genuine and effective checks-and-balances system.

The possibilities opened by the first entrepreneurial turn were still limited by the existence of the allegedly necessary evil of institutionalized violence. The possibilities opened by the second entrepreneurial turn can be endless. The information age provides ample illustration of this optimistic perspective – we have already witnessed the entrepreneurial creation of many sophisticated institutional frameworks in the digital space, frameworks that are genuinely self-policing and that offer its users a multitude of extraordinary services. The Bitcoin infrastructure and Wikipedia are just two of the most obvious examples in this context. One can only wonder how extraordinary the results of unleashing the same entrepreneurial spirit in “physical” space would be.

Violence, especially in its organized and centralized form, necessarily eliminates all competition in the area of creating institutional frameworks for entrepreneurial action. Thus, it eliminates a practically infinite number of opportunities for commercial and broadly social advancement, offering in return what, due to its monopolistic, coercive nature can hardly be said to meet the logical criteria of a genuine good or service. One might hope that the time is ripe for this realization to provide a powerful catalyst for the second entrepreneurial turn, the one that will bring to completion the civilizing process of substituting cooperative liberty for parasitic power.

Sunday, March 3, 2013

The Free Market is the Only Real Public Good

The free market is the only real public good, since, as the sum total of voluntary interactions between people, it is the only good whose creation and perpetuation meets the criterion of strictly unanimous, and thus genuinely public acceptance.